Reviews for Sherrill New York Pizzeria

04/13/2025 - Bart Y.
I found this awesome pizza joint where the prices won't break the bank and the service is super quick. I grabbed a slice and a Stromboli, and I was blown away by the sweet sauce and generous toppings-they really know how to do it right! The owner and staff were super friendly, and I can't wait to go back for more, especially that chicken wing pizza with onion and bacon!

08/30/2024 - Bea B.
The pizza joint I hit up had really affordable prices and I was in and out super quick. I gotta say, those garlic knots were legit - tasty and easy on the wallet. The pizza had this sweet sauce that was killer, wish I had ordered a whole pie! It's the real deal if you're craving awesome pizza and other goodies like wraps and subs.

09/10/2023 - Jerry Kramer
We had magets in our pizza !
I was with my children
My daughter started to scream
We just left
The parking lot had a strong smell of Marijuana which I had to explain to my 5 year old daughter Never again!

02/06/2021 - MenuPix User
Best chicken wing pizza ive ever had and other menu options dont dissapoint. Great food and great staff!