Reviews for Whitesville House Tavern

01/10/2024 - MenuPix User

07/08/2023 - Bob
Place has gone to the toilet

10/01/2021 - Kelcee
My husband and I ate there and wanted to watch the Penn State game but never again. We got the philly and it was a nasty mess. Like the bun just fell apart. The cheese was just laid on top and not melte My husband and I ate there to stay and watch the Penn State game but never again. We got the philly and it was a nasty mess. Like the bun just fell apart. The cheese was just laid on top and not melted or nothing. Just two Kraft singles on a pile of sloppy dry meat. The bartender was shady too at the least. She kept running into the bathroom and out to the porch. Took her like forever anytime we wanted a drink. The food took forever too. I just had the fries my husbands came with and tried to eat some of his mess. We only had three drinks and a glass of water between us and “split” the sandwich (that we didn’t eat) and our bill was over 50 bucks! That’s insane! For a garbage sanwhich, fries, some stale chips (which I’m glad they didn’t charge us for or I would have lost it there) two Stellas and whatever they call their orange drink (I don’t remember what it was called but it was literally OJ and tonic in the smallest glass you’ve ever seen) and a cup of ice water. When we asked they said the sandwich was like 25 bucks (not including the fries that was my dinner and most of his) even though the menu said like 16 or something I don’t remember exactly. I can’t believe they can get away with that. It was all bad. The service, the food, the drinks. The drinks weren’t even like brand. They were just crappy bottom shelf well. I don’t think it was really liquor, or maybe it was watered down, I don’t know. And they had nothing on tap at all. Just like the spots where taps are supposed to go and nothing there. I don’t know why they even call it a bar. I guess the only good thing about it was that there was plenty of space inside so we know it must be how they do it there. Never again guys. Insane prices, crazy bad drinks, sloppy greasy food. I will give them one silver lining, the fries were alright, kind of bland but much better than the cheesesteak.

07/26/2020 - bob pfuntner
excellent food and service