Reviews for Holy Cow Idaho

01/26/2024 - MenuPix User

09/28/2023 - MenuPix User
Eagle location is just as delicious as the Nampa location. Aimee was a great server. She recommended the Taco Special and they were sooooo good. If you go on a Tuesday....get the tacos! Burgers are also excellent!

06/03/2023 - Diane
I stopped in early afternoon after seeing some rave reviews of Holy Cow. I really wanted to love this place but found it pretty average. I ordered the Sawtooth Steak Melt ($18) which looked great and had nice flavor. The steak was a solid gray and some pieces were pretty chewy. The fries were nicely seasoned. The Strawberry and White Pepper Margarita ($11 or $12) was a disappointment. The description indicated there was a pepper syrup in it but I didn’t get any pepper or spice notes. It tasted like a mild strawberry margarita. In retrospect Holy Cow seems more geared to beer than cocktails. The service was outstanding but there were only 2-3 customers.

I don’t mind paying for good food but I felt the food was average at best and a little overpriced. The restaurant interior was nondescript but there was a nice little patio. I love supporting local businesses but there was nothing that stood out that would make me want to return. The reality is that there are other similarly priced restaurants that have better food and cocktails.

05/27/2023 - Mrs Evans
Friday, 5/26/23
Ate here today & it was such a huge disappointment on every level; food, fountain drink & SERVICE!
The first time we ate here was shortly after they opened & it was a wonderful experience. NOT this time!! Food undercooked & over salted, cola drink watery. Was only able to eat a few bites. No water was served & couldn't get the attention of the bartender so I could ask for some and she NEVER once checked back with us. Tried to get her attention so we could get our check to pay for our meals & leave,but she was too busy yuking it up with "guys" on the other side of the bar. She finally walked away from them & looked our way & I called out to her to bring us our check. It was very loud inside the room & I'm 80 yrs old and somewhat hard of hearing. She came over with the check & then asked me why I yelled at her, and I replyed that it was so noisey & I couldn't hear. She was so rude and I was embarrassed. What a pitiful experience and I don't recommend anyone eating here and we certainly won't be recommending it to our friends or family. Too bad because it's a great location