Reviews for Mayflower Seafood Restaurant

07/21/2025 - Little R.
When we arrived, the restaurant was buzzing with customers and the waitress was constantly on the move, which made sense once we learned about the half-price Wednesday deal. The food was flavorful with generous portions-especially the fried flounder, hush puppies, and loaded baked potato-and the service from Amber and Erin was friendly and attentive, making it an experience worth repeating.

01/31/2025 - Just D.
As we arrived, the bustling atmosphere of the restaurant caught me off guard with its full parking lot and lively crowd, all thanks to the 50% off Wednesday special. The food was plentiful and packed with flavor, especially the fried flounder and hush puppies, making me look forward to returning for another satisfying meal.

04/19/2024 - Nigel O.
AMAZING

01/24/2023 - MenuPix User
Always fresh and fast great food

12/19/2022 - Scottie Little
They have the best broiled whitefish and shrimp plate that I have ever eaten

10/11/2022 - MenuPix User
Great food and price

05/09/2022 - Marie Kirk
I love this seafood place, None better in the USA!!! I am from N C but now in Wisconsin, And I hate you don't have a restaurant here!!😢 So I am on my way to visit in June, 2022!! So excited!! Yummy 🐠 Fish!! 😊 Thanks. Marie

03/16/2022 - MenuPix User
Good food, large portions and friendly staff.

12/16/2021 - MenuPix User
Worst service tonight (12/15) I have ever had at this place !!!

12/07/2021 - Brian
Poorest display of a seafood platter I've ever seen grease soaked very over salted poor quality seafood I feel sorry for the fish that is cooked by this.place and the patrons i would be ashamed to serve it to anyone

11/16/2021 - Rshonda Corpening
Very disappointed in the quality of the food. I had not been to the May flower in over 4 years....Bad decision...The waitress was ok..I will never go back to this place! The food was Terrible!!

11/10/2021 - MenuPix User
The scallops are delicious

03/28/2021 - MenuPix User
Been there several times... never had a bad experience, food and service is always great

01/05/2021 - MenuPix User
The food is terriffic and the service is friendly and fast. It's my favorite seafood place to go. The prices are reasonable too. Try it out, you will like it.

05/22/2020 - Joyce Menius
Always loved eating here.