Reviews for Papa Nicks Original Pizza

07/18/2025 - Kenia J.
During a family weekend getaway, I ordered an Italian sub for takeout and appreciated the easy parking and smooth carryout window experience. The pizza was fantastic with a great crust and fresh toppings, while the garlic knots, though heavy on garlic, were clearly homemade and unique. The cozy, friendly atmosphere and attentive service made the meal enjoyable, and I look forward to returning to try more of their delicious dishes.

10/17/2024 - Julie H.
Ordered an Italian sub over the phone and parking was a breeze. Simply walked up to the window for pickup without having to step inside. The sandwich was tasty and the Greek salad was a hit, though the garlic knots were a bit heavy on the garlic flavor. The pizza was outstanding, worth the wait, and the service was friendly in a cozy dining setting.

07/15/2024 - Star O.
Nifty

03/29/2023 - MenuPix User
We have been enjoying Papa Nicks pizza since they were in their old location on the hill. The crust tastes buttery and the toppings are always fresh. The pizza sauce cannot be compared with any other pizza I have ever had, including in Italy. It's yummy. I now live out of state, so getting to Papa Nicks while in town is a "must do". It is quite a treat!

11/28/2014 - Bob
Awsome