Reviews for Carmelas Pizza & Italian

10/15/2024 - Nicole L.
The service was friendly and efficient, making our lunch stop enjoyable during our road trip to Virginia. The thin crust pizza was perfectly cooked, with just the right balance of softness and crispiness, pleasing both my daughter and husband with their respective orders. The fresh salad bar and delicious meals made us wish we lived closer so we could return for another satisfying dining experience at Carmela's.

06/14/2024 - Gracie R.
so good

08/29/2023 - Kathy soyars
Food is always good and drive thru service great

04/17/2023 - Vicki Carver
Carmelas Pizza is the best!! The cheese 🧀 they use is so creamy and tastes wonderful! They have the best Pizza 🍕 😋 in the Greensboro, Stokesdale and Reidsville area!! Only wish you had another Restaurant closer to Stokesdale!! Keep up the great work 👍 I would drive further than Stokesdale, if I had to, just to get Camel's Pizza 🍕 😋 It is soooooo YUMMY 😋

09/24/2020 - Kathy soyars
Excellent food

03/25/2020 - MenuPix User
Carmelas Personal Pan Pizza is the best one in town.
Retired Goodyear worker.

08/17/2018 - Megan A.
What can I say except "I love it"

11/16/2014 - Tucker
Wow is all I can say! What a great change this place has become. This restaurant is so much better than it used to be. The specials they have on the weekends are top notch. The pizza is better than any restaurants around Reidsville and the stromboli I had a week ago is probebly the best stromboli within 100 miles. There are some pretty good italian dishes on the menu. A friend of mine said the steak and cheese subs are as good as it gets south of philly. Havent tried it yet but will. Thank you guys for the clean restaurant and the excellent pizza. I regret ever eating Bono Pizza. My opinion go to Carmelas and enjoy a fresh italian meal in Reidsville instead of the crap most restaurants give you around here!

08/01/2014 - Randy Davenport
We have been to this restraunt several times since they reopened. It used to be our favorite place. The 1st 3 times we went after the new opening were terrible. The staff didn't know what they were doing and the orders were wrong. We said we'd never go back. After a couple months we decided to give them another shot. Turned out OK and I took my son once and again OK. Tonight we showed up on Friday night at 8:35. The sign on the door states that they close at 9:00. They turned us away saying they stop taking orders at 8:30 and they have a family too! We told them we won't be back and they seemed unphased. From now on Bona Pizza will be getting our business! Oh...and they need a new roof..buckets were sittng around the lobby catching rain water. Makes me think mold might be growing in the ceiling!