Reviews for Castaways

06/24/2025 - Colin Z.
The appetizers here truly hit a home run, especially the infamous O burger, which is a deliciously stuffed and deep-fried masterpiece that blends flavors perfectly despite its indulgence. The beachy, laid-back atmosphere combined with friendly service, large portions, and a diverse menu-including incredible wings and crispy thin-crust pizza-makes it a favorite destination for family meals and casual dining, even if you need to be patient with the wait times.

11/30/2024 - Kristine H.
The food at Castaways in Chillicothe exceeded my expectations, especially the O Burger and wings. The beachy decor and friendly staff make it a favorite spot for my family, despite some wait times for the fresh, made-to-order dishes.

06/06/2023 - Nancy
Everything was good except for pattymelt. Very dry not much taste. Onions weren't grilled kind of disappointing. Waitress was very nice.

06/20/2021 - Tom Bishop
I came here thinking it was a dump . Guess what it's a total dump ! So after my meal I left a dump on bathroom floor . Good day to you sir !

09/21/2014 - Bob
Worst experience ever!! Order came wrong, then brought another that was wrong. To top this the third plate was the first plate redone(could see where I cut it). YUCK reserving food!!! Said they wouldn't charge for the plate and would get something else free. So reordered that plate was just nasty. So I got up and left.