Reviews for Amici's Pizza

05/20/2025 - Margie Lake
Well won't be eating here again. My daughter ordered a half pep and half cheese pizza. They delivered a whole pep and cheese. My grandchildren only eat cheese pizza. We ate some pep and cheese, the 14 yr old took the pep off but the 4 yr old just wouldn't do it lol so my daughter called and complained. They did the right thing and brought a pizza done right out then ask for the 1st pizza back? Seriously? In all my 59 yrs I've never had any honorable establishment ask for the 1st, messed up order, back! I do believe this goes against some kind of health code? Maybe he was just hungry? I am sad because I loved their food but I don't appreciate that kind of treatment after we always tip great!

05/25/2024 - Matthew O.
Best food and service

07/18/2022 - Ayaz Hasham.
Great. As Always.

08/02/2020 - MenuPix User
Wonderful food good prices great people definitely 5 Stars

02/09/2019 - MenuPix User
Even from your Facebook page the website you have listed leads to amicis San Francisco. It's annoying but your pizza is delicious so whatever. 😋 Delivery is usually fast and I've never had an order come out wrong. Amicis also is a big supporter of Ridgewood school district and it gives us a lot of hometown pride.

02/25/2014 - mousepad
This place deserves less than the 1 star I was forced to give it. bathrooms horrible, décor horrible, and the pizza was overpriced and undercooked with low quality ingredients (frozen from a Sysco truck, not fresh) this place is unique in the fact that it's few patrons actually eat their cardboard. We wont be back, and that's a five star promise.