Reviews for Hilltop Pizza Shop

02/28/2025 - Joe X.
This hidden treasure just across the PA line offers the best pepperoni rolls I've ever tasted, and I've tried many across the country. The pizza is excellent, the service is friendly, and supporting this family-oriented shop is a decision you won't regret.

05/21/2024 - Bubba O.
AWESOME

06/21/2023 - Suzan
Best local pizzeria! Large pizza with lots of delicious sauce, cheese and any toppings you decide to order. I happen to love their sausage. Dough is always cooked perfectly. Treat yourself and order one today!

02/07/2023 - Jim
One or two pizza places I would order from

07/06/2022 - Tammy
Been going here for years and they make the best pizza

06/22/2022 - MenuPix User
Slow service and burnt pizza

10/13/2019 - Sue s
Excellent pierogie pizza delivered in a timely fashion by Wes. He was very personable and spoke highly of the care that goes into the making of the pizza. I now live in Phila, and this is the BEST pierogie pizza I've found. Highly recommended!!!

09/04/2016 - Tammy
Excellent! Has a strong, bold flavor for the sauce. Good price. Wish I could get it here in MN. I get it every time I go home!

06/19/2013 - tommy
delish pizza