Reviews for Jay's Pizza

07/17/2025 - Evelyn M.
At 70, I've never tasted pizza this delicious with sweet sauce and perfect crust. We drive from Wooster three times a month just to enjoy Jay's amazing, affordable pizza.

03/02/2025 - Jordan M.
At 70 years old, I have yet to experience pizza that compares to this extraordinary creation, which captures the hearts of everyone I introduce it to. With its sweet, delicious sauce and the option for half-baked orders, I find myself driving from Wooster three times a month, eagerly savoring each bite of double crust pepperoni that awaits me whenever I return to Massillon.

04/20/2024 - Karen C.
AWESOME!

12/11/2022 - Bill
Best pizza we have had in a long time we drive from Akron to get it

09/16/2018 - MenuPix User
It's odd that their menu doesn't have pizza on it, hence the name of their establishment. Poor marketing!

05/27/2018 - Mindylynn
My daughter is getting ready to graduate this year and this is her favorite pizza ever since she's been a little girl they have great food Not Just Pizza Wings appetizers and you can't forget about the Bubba Burgers delicious highly recommended

11/06/2016 - Jazzy
They have the best pizza in Massillon!!!

06/06/2016 - donna
love it, favorite Pizza and im not a person who cares for pizza. ;)
price is fair, always have leftovers

10/19/2015 - bootsy
This is the BEST PIZZA IN MASSILLON

12/04/2011 - robert
great pizza for a reasonable price