Reviews for Jerry's Pizza

06/25/2025 - Che H.
Jerry's Pizza in Chillicothe serves thin-crust, finely chopped topping pizzas with a nostalgic, dive-bar atmosphere. The service can be slow, but the pizza, prices, and unique style keep me coming back for more.

08/22/2024 - Mikayla M.
The small, cozy pizzeria has a simple and friendly atmosphere that hasn't changed over the years. The pizzas are unique with very thin crusts and toppings like tiny bits of mushroom and sausage. While the cheese pizza may have oregano and garlic, opting for the plain cheese could be best for those who prefer a simpler flavor profile.

06/25/2024 - Ray S.
Love this place

07/09/2016 - D Fran
I was so very disappoint. Went here the other day. The pizza was not what it use to be. Jerry's West is much better ask the way around. Service on Paint was not the greatest. We asked for boxes and waited a half hour before getting up and asking again. The waitress was behind the bar talking to customers that had been there before us and shoving french fries into her mouth. Have never had that on the West side. Needless to say avoiding Paint St from now on.