Reviews for Josie's Pizza Shop

04/14/2023 - Sandy
From $4.25 for the small 6" pizza to $8.25 is ridiculous!! I won't go there again.

06/09/2021 - Lawlis
Patrons since 74.

03/22/2021 - Dan
Great pizza

03/11/2021 - MenuPix User
I was one of the regulars at the original Hot Dog Shop in New Brighton, Pa. They had the best milkshakes ever. Had a milkshake at Josie's 2 weeks ago...after 40 years found a milkshake comparable to the Hot Dog Shop at Josie's !!!

02/01/2021 - Jeri Sommers
Still as good as 40 years ago!

01/13/2021 - MenuPix User
Best pizza in town

01/05/2021 - MenuPix User
Best pizza ever!!

10/11/2020 - John/Cathy Wilms
Great tasting chicken dinner and picture perfect/tasting pizza. Delicious!!

06/25/2020 - George
Always great tasting food/ pizza

05/26/2020 - MenuPix User
The second time getting pizza from Josies, since reopening. The kids loved it since we brought them down to Marietta Georgia. My sons haven't had this since they were home last year

02/27/2020 - Zac
Good food love the pizza

09/03/2019 - Mike
Awesome pizza! I've never been disappointed yet.

02/21/2016 - Joe Runyon
I have been eating Josie's Pizza for about 40 years. That many years as a loyal and satisfied customer says it all. Many other pizza shops have come and gone, but in Salem, Josie's is still the best !