Reviews for McCarthy's Restaurant & Pub

04/26/2025 - Benjamin L.
I had a blast at McCarthy's, and the food was really tasty! The traditional Irish dishes were comforting and flavorful, plus the rye bread was spot on. Service was friendly and attentive, making it an awesome spot for a drink and a bite, and I can't wait to come back!

01/13/2025 - Mollie K.
I had a great time at McCarthys - the food was delicious and the atmosphere was cozy. The staff was friendly and the Guinness was spot on. The shepherd's pie was a standout dish, full of flavor and hearty goodness.

06/08/2024 - Mitchell S.
Good people

05/02/2023 - MenuPix User
Had dinner there last evening. So cold, I guess no heat on. Luckily us 3 had our jackets. Wooden tables only and hard wooden chairs. Sky high prices. 6 wings plus fries, $19.00 and that's what I wanted. No way, got burger and fries, $13.00, but delicious. So noisy with loud music. Small crowd and that was dinner time. Won't go back. My 2 friends like irish food, that's why we went there. I'll take Fast Eddie's wings, fries and pizza any day.

04/17/2023 - MenuPix User
Nice atmosphere if you want to have a few drinks and watch a game. Plenty of TVs
If you're planning on eating...think twice!!
Very limited menu. And when I was there, some items where unavailable....So I had the fish and chips. BIG MISTAKE!!
Below average at best and when the bill came I nearly fell on the floor...$26.00. I had an iced tea to drink. I could have went down the street to Jolley Rodgers and had fresh lake Erie perch for less than that.
Never again.

03/13/2023 - MenuPix User
Amazing food.
Awesome service & great atmosphere

06/13/2009 - JH
Meh. Average food, average service. Typical decor. The only Irish themed pub in town so I guess it's got that going for you. Not kid friendly on the weekends....