Reviews for Sarah's Pizza

05/04/2024 - Deepak D.
Great

04/23/2024 - Julian B.
I absolutely love Sara's pizza, especially the one in Brookville! The staff there is super friendly, and the food is always delicious. I highly recommend trying the mashed potato pizza - it's surprisingly good and has become my go-to order whenever I'm craving pizza!

10/28/2022 - MenuPix User
It's good

02/12/2022 - MenuPix User
Live this pizza. Best

09/06/2021 - Cindy Worley
Just awful, first my husband shows up , pays, is told 7 minutes, he waits, and waits, and waits, girl shows up, someone asks any idea how long i have to wait for my order, hubby says well i got here at quarter til, told 7 minutes, it is now a half hour, guy brings food over says sorry. Hubby said he told him NEVER AGAIN, gets food home, seasoned wedges burnt, cold inedible throw them out, open box with my ten wings the flats all stuck to tinfoil peels off the skin to unsticks 2 burnt and thrown out, disgusted, wasted $22 on crap! We will never ever order from Brookville Saras again!

09/02/2021 - MenuPix User
Always great food and great delivery. Love the pizza and steak subs - but can't go wrong with anything. Tip them well - the food is worth it!

06/04/2021 - Michael Cook
I live close so I don't order online. I've ordered most of the menu items for carryout and have never had a bad experience. Pizzas are great. Subs are also top notch. Beats corporate giant Pizza Hut by leaps and bounds. People are friendly and everything I've ordered is on time and ready to go. I turned several of my friends who live out of town onto Sarah's and they were hooked.

02/07/2021 - Mary durham
Love the food just wish you would open sooner than 3. Sarah’s would be a great place for lunch.

05/20/2020 - MenuPix User
I have tried to place and order - the online is very user unfriendly and the telephone doesn't work.

08/04/2018 - Winifred Arenas
Love their taco pizza