Reviews for Sarah's Pizza & Subs

04/29/2025 - Anna S.
The pizza here is some of the best I've tasted, with fresh ingredients and a perfectly balanced sauce that doesn't overwhelm the flavors. While they do have some hiccups with their ordering process, the friendly staff and great prices make it a worthwhile choice in Eaton.

10/01/2024 - Justin Y.
The pizza joint serves up some delicious pies, but their delivery service can be a bit hit or miss when things get busy. I usually resort to using my Papa John's app when I can't get through to them on the phone. My tip is to call in your order early in the day for pickup later to avoid the rush. The cheese stick pizza and extra-large pepperoni are worth the wait, but they could use some extra hands in the kitchen to speed things up.

06/24/2024 - Hiram B.
Great food and service.

02/28/2015 - Kristi
Love the pizza

04/13/2010 - Brad
Great pizza great subs crazy fast delivery best cheese stix ever just sucks they dont open until 3 always want it for lunch but never available.