Reviews for P J's Sandwich Shoppe

06/03/2025 - Tiara H.
After hearing neighbors rave about it, I checked out the menu at this cozy, family-owned sandwich shop in Tulsa and found the ham, pineapple, and cream cheese sandwich delicious, along with excellent sides like potato and pasta salad, friendly service, homemade food that tastes like comfort from grandma's kitchen, generous portions, a welcoming atmosphere reminiscent of simpler times, and thoughtful touches like free dessert with cash payments, making it a favorite I plan to visit regularly.

05/20/2024 - Kayden G.
Great

06/12/2019 - Debbie Fann
They have the best drip beef in town!!

06/13/2018 - tulsanative
It's hard for me to post this because the food it good.

My problem is that the communication is extremely poor from one to another. My to go order is 8 out of 10 times incorrect, from what I ask not to include/include to the way it's rung up at the register, then when I correct them I must offend them in such a way they don't apologize they just make up excuses or place blame on the next.

Frustrated for sure but the food is good, not sure if it's worth all they charge but it is good.

03/25/2016 - kk
1st & last time for me. service unfriendly, to go order not turned in for 30 minutes while I waited, with no apologies made. worst meatloaf ever (orange colored mush) asked for mayo & ketchup, got mustard. over priced & over rated.

07/31/2010 - Sarah Filler
I love P.J.'s!!! The food is always fresh and filling and generously priced. Not to mention the people that work there always have a smile on their face and you can tell that they truly enjoy sharing Tulsa's Best "Kept Secret." I would highly recommend this restaurant and their famous and delicious chicken salad!

03/31/2010 - Carol Glasgow
The food is always so good and they have the BEST chicken salad...not full of huge chunks of celery. The staff is friendly and helpful. I highly recommend.