Reviews for Geraldi's Italian Eating Place

02/03/2025 - Marlo G.
Stepping inside reveals an inviting atmosphere with incredible aromas that immediately capture the attention. The spicy Geraldi toasted sandwich and meatball sub I ordered were exceptional, with tender meatballs and perfectly balanced sauce. The friendly staff and owner, who personally ensured our experience was memorable, made it easy to see why this family-run establishment has such a loyal following.

05/14/2024 - Mika C.
Good home cooking

03/28/2023 - MenuPix User
Such an amazing restaurant! My family and I have been eating here for years and the food is always great, the service is amazing, and it's truly a family-run restaurant. The owner Joe does such a great job and is always so welcoming and friendly!

01/26/2021 - Vicki Allen
Every time I have eaten at Geraldi's in McMinnville it was a satisfying experience. Excellent food and the friendliness of the staff and owner is wonderful. They want to be sure you have what you want by checking to make sure all is okay. Geraldi's is the only pizza place in McMinnville that I visit.

01/13/2020 - KA
Delicious NY tsyle pizza. Im from New York so my husband and I were thrilled to find this place. The sauce is awesome. Cheese is generous and the dough is divine!

11/11/2019 - MenuPix User
Everything from scratch, nothing left to chance & not afraid of cheese!