Reviews for Wally's Bagels

06/26/2025 - Hi K.
The bagels here are consistently fresh, generously topped with cream cheese, and come in a wide variety of delicious flavors that keep me coming back time and again. Despite the busy crowds, the friendly staff work efficiently to ensure fast service, making every visit a satisfying experience.

05/06/2024 - Kam R.
Fantastic

04/25/2023 - Steve
Layla got a free Black and White Cookie from her best buddy Ahmed, the manager of Wally's Bagels

12/21/2022 - Ellen Whitaker
Been going to Wally's for over 25 yrs. No other bagel store will do. .

09/05/2021 - MenuPix User
Great bagel. My only problem is them changing gloves after handling money. Maybe other people are ok with that. This is not good hygiene when handling food.

07/03/2021 - Katherine Paterson
Not only are Wally's Bagels the best bagels on Long Island the best bagel I've ever had I moved to Georgia and I come back to New York at least five or six times a year on my way back my first stop before the airport you guessed it Wally's Bagels the best

05/09/2021 - Jim
The only place to go for fast service and the best bagel around. Can't compare. Always a line of people but they move through fast.

10/26/2020 - Nona
Biggest Bagels ever!! Delicious,friendly staff and very quick!! 5 stars🥰👍👍

05/27/2020 - Penny H
Best, biggest and greatest selection of bagels on LI!