Reviews for Sontheimer's Country Bakery

06/27/2025 - Raquel C.
During a recent trip through Erie, I stopped by a local bakery near Presque Isle that brought back so many childhood memories with its fresh, homemade baked goods. The cinnamon rolls were incredibly fluffy and perfectly balanced in sweetness, making me wish I had bought more, and the friendly staff made the experience even better. It felt like a little taste of home, with prices that were surprisingly affordable for the quality and care evident in every pastry.

06/19/2024 - Antonio A.
good

10/04/2023 - Nancy
The best bakery. Full of so much 😋 deliciousness. #1 choice for me.

07/05/2023 - Kathy Jane
Best pastries in town !!!!
I have been enjoying these delicious goodies for over 40 years now👍

02/25/2023 - Cherie Lachowski
Everything has an amazing taste- the friendly staff is just like family. Erie is so lucky to have a quality bakery like this😊

01/18/2023 - Penny Best
EVERYTHING I have tried here has been absolutely delicious. Their pastries and cakes are so fresh. I especially love their maple frosted items. I love love love this bakery!

08/10/2022 - Mary
Nicest people and best bakery!!!!

06/07/2022 - Deb Kovach
Love the orange moon cakes!! Trying to figure out a way to get some delivered to Florida. Ate them as a kid. Youngest son loves them!

03/03/2022 - Barb Macek
Love Sontheimers Backery everyone is always very helpful!!

03/17/2021 - MenuPix User
My family has been patronizing Sontheimer's for years. All of their baked goods are delicious! I drive from Dunkirk, NY just to purchase from them.

01/02/2021 - Jill
The owner was extremely rude to me when I said I'd pay with plastic..horrible rude...is this how you keep customers? I also heard her talk about other customers while in line so unprofessional

03/06/2020 - MenuPix User
Great morning pastries. Excellent whipped cream cake. Fabulous cookies. The line you will have to wait in says it all

05/07/2017 - J. Thompen
These are hard working, honest merchants and their product is a testimony to their many years of skill. Yum yum and natural ingredients...