Reviews for Warrington Pastry Shop

06/02/2025 - Ma B.
I ordered a themed cake and cupcakes for my daughter's baby shower, and the baker was super helpful, really listening to what I wanted and making great suggestions to bring the vision to life. Everything arrived right on time, looked amazing, and tasted even better-moist, flavorful, and fresh-earning tons of compliments from everyone at the party.

01/03/2025 - Evan B.
Planning my daughter's baby shower, I discovered the Warrington Pastry Shop for ordering the cake and cupcakes. The baker was fantastic, creating a themed cake that looked and tasted amazing, making the party a hit!

05/05/2024 - Dave B.
Great Experience!

06/15/2023 - MenuPix User
STAFF ALWAYS POLITE AND THE DONUTS ETC ARE GREAT

03/18/2023 - Horrible baked good with rude owner
Don't shop here. Bought $20 worth of baked good with rancid walnuts. Owner was rude and would t give me a refund. Rudest person ever!

07/24/2021 - Mike K
High quality baked goods homemade taste!!.Try this location you will not be disappointed.. Professionally decorated cakes for all occasions..one of the best bakeries in the tri state area..

05/28/2021 - Warrington
It's hit or miss. The cakes and muffins are often dry and over baked.

12/22/2020 - Jim D
You must try the sticky buns and dinner rolls. So light and airy. You can tell they are made with love.

11/10/2020 - MenuPix User
A find for those of us who miss the Philadelphia bakeries of the 40's, 50', 60's. Highlights: Cinnamon buns, Crumb Cakes, Cookies, Cannoli's, Iced white cakes. Very pleasant, helpful staff.

06/09/2020 - Mike K
Exceptional bakery products and beautifully decorated cakes !! One of the best all around bakeries to be found anywhere!!
Butter cake..pound cake.. Danish.. carrot cake..and possibly the best cheese cake on the east coast..

05/01/2020 - MenuPix User
Best around