Reviews for Colarusso's Italian
| 5 stars |
|
|
9 votes - | 45% |
| 4 stars |
|
|
8 votes - | 40% |
| 3 stars |
|
|
1 votes - | 5% |
| 2 stars |
|
|
1 votes - | 5% |
| 1 star |
|
|
1 votes - | 5% |
Latest MenuPix Reviews
06/08/2025 - Old S.
The double stuffed white pizza and the red pizza are absolutely fantastic, with fresh ingredients and a delicious, authentic taste that stands out among Old Forge styles. The homemade meatballs and sausages pair perfectly with the fresh salads, creating a well-rounded meal every time. The friendly staff and warm, community-oriented atmosphere make every visit enjoyable, and the consistent quality keeps me coming back whenever I'm in the area.
10/05/2024 - Candice L.
The white pizza with double stuffing is absolutely delicious! Additionally, the red pizza is quite tasty. Finally, the meatball and sausage platter is a must-try. The atmosphere is great, and it's definitely the best pizza in the Old Forge area. People are friendly and the food is always fresh.
07/02/2024 - Mark W.
Fave
01/25/2022 - Al
Very good food terrible parking
05/08/2019 - MenuPix User
You don't do round pies?
10/14/2011 - Mary
Awful, the pizza is lousy and other stuff is NOT HOMEMADE
Staff is rude I have no clue how they have the business that they have - I guess the NEPA people are NOT food savy!
Will not return, better places ust up the road with really good food and inviting!