Reviews for Tally Ho Restaurant

08/19/2025 - Shannon R.
We attended the opening night of the season and enjoyed a buffet featuring four entrí©es, a fresh salad bar, an array of vegetables, rolls, and desserts-all bursting with homemade flavor. The ambiance was casual and inviting, complemented by attentive service that felt natural rather than intrusive. Nestled in a historic Victorian hotel dating back to 1888, each uniquely styled room blends vintage charm with modern comforts, making it an authentic Chautauqua experience paired perfectly with hearty, home-cooked meals at a reasonable price.

09/30/2024 - Anthony R.
On the opening night of the season, the buffet was the only dining option available, but it offered a selection of four entrees, a salad bar with fresh ingredients and various vegetables, as well as rolls and dessert. The atmosphere was casual and relaxed, with service that was attentive but not overbearing. The historic Chautauqua setting provided a unique experience, perfect for those seeking a quaint Victorian hotel with modern amenities at a reasonable price.

07/04/2024 - Josette W.
Awesome

07/23/2014 - Bruce
2014 mid July. I ordered turkey cobb salad. Turkey slices were dry and tough. Overall, salad was poor. Other diners in our group also had below average meals. Tally Ho does not accept credit cards - which we only discovered as we paid our bill.