Reviews for Colonia Supreme Bagels

07/23/2024 - Brittany S.
This bagel shop is my absolute favorite destination for a delicious breakfast. Every time I visit, I love the variety of cream cheeses and breakfast drinks they offer, along with the friendly and efficient staff that make the experience enjoyable. If you're planning to order a breakfast sandwich or a large order, it's best to call ahead to avoid any potential delays during busy times.

07/22/2017 - Gwen Hall
I have been going here for years. I usually call in my order and pick it up at the drive thru. 8 out of 10 times its wrong!!!! Why do I keep going back?? It's convenient and the bagels are good. I usually go back after a few months hoping they had gotten better. NOPE!!!!! This morning I called in a Taylor ham and cheese on everything bagel and toasted buttered everything. When I got home and looked in the bag I had a Taylor ham and cheese on everything bagel and a untoasted everything with cream cheese. HOW DID THIS HAPPEN WHEN THE BOY WHO TOOK MY ORDER READ IT BACK TO ME????? It's par for the course here unfortunately. The owner is such a nice guy. He really needs to find more competent help than these young kids who just don't care. Oh well, I think it's time to find a new favorite bagel store. Ugh