Reviews for Goodfellos Pizza Pasta and Grille

10/16/2024 - Jessica B.
The food and service at this local Italian restaurant are consistently exceptional, with a standout being their delicious pizza and hoagies. The staff is friendly and efficient, making every dining experience enjoyable and worth returning for.

07/12/2024 - William P.
The best in town

01/16/2022 - Judy Edwards
Great food!

05/06/2021 - Brad
Me n my family order from Goodfello's continuously and the reason is because the food is supremely excellent. Only complaint is that depending on who is working depends on how accurate the order is. Do not know for sure who is at fault completely. But, it's not a consistent problem. And let me stress that the quality of the food and selection is so very awesome that it is not enough of a deterrent or mind changer. The menu and quality of all food items are fantastic. I am quick to spread the good word about the great qualities of the restaurant. After I finish this review I will be on their website deciding what to order!!

02/19/2021 - Study customer
Your food is magnificent. Alot of us girls love it to

02/03/2021 - Merle Love
Great Food

01/13/2021 - Brenda Segafredo
We really loved going there. With the virus we dont know any other place a Goodfellows. Prices are great. Delivery is fantastic. It very close to home. Its here in town.

12/03/2020 - Nicole
Terrible experience! The food was fine however, it was over $40 for 2 salads and a sub and delivery took almost 2 full hours. (I was told 60 min at the time of order) then food arrived barely warm.

10/16/2020 - Philip Wall
Good food and good people

08/06/2020 - Returning Customer
This place is great! Friendly staff and good prices. Love the variety and the food is always amazing!

08/01/2020 - Crystal
Love the grilled chicken salad, hot sausage casserole, bacon cheese fries and pizza at Goodfellos. We order at least once a week!

07/13/2018 - MIKE
I eat here 2 to 3 times a week. They have a variety of food that my family and I enjoy

04/22/2017 - suckmyass
waited an hour 10 minutes food cold

03/11/2016 - Jim
Best Pizza around! I'm from Grove City and will make the trip again for a pizza.

01/16/2016 - Brenda Segafredo
I love there food and staff and waitress are fantastic. The one in Zelienople is the best we go at least once or twice a week. If you haven't yet visited this restaurant it would be a great time

11/16/2013 - Patty skalos
Pulled pork sandwiches to die for. Ordering for my sons high school graduation party. YUM!!!!!

07/13/2013 - Laura
The stuffed shells were delicious and the service was great. The pizza was okay. I would eat there regularly.