Reviews for Johnny's New York Style Pizza

05/31/2024 - Tara B.
The food at Johnny's in West Point is consistently delicious, and the hardworking employees always make the experience enjoyable. The pizza is hot, fresh, and full of flavor, making it a local favorite that I will definitely be returning to in the future.

12/29/2015 - Melissa W.
I've eaten here multiple times and have never had any real problem. Good food, decent prices, friendly service. It's mine and my preschooler's favorite place to eat at in town.

12/14/2014 - Jenifer Siggars
Their food is awful. We tired it one Wednesday night before church. there was about 20 of us & we phoned ahead to let them know we were coming. No one liked what they got. They seemed to make mistakes on all our orders. They sure do not serve real Italian food. We tried each others food. None of us liked the food or service. No one ate much on their plates. Over priced too. There was a piece of plastic cooked into the pizza the pastor got. It covered about 1/3 of his food. They brought him another one but I t was burned to a crisp. Same with about everything w ordered. the lasagna had undercooked noodles. YUCK!