Reviews for Anthony's Pizza

12/07/2024 - Melanie F.
We absolutely adore Anthony's during their brief closure for renovations. The owner, Lou, and his assistant, Ally, always go above and beyond to assist me, especially with carrying my food to the car. Their food is truly exceptional - we haven't ordered pizzas or cheese steaks from anywhere else since tasting the delicious offerings at Anthony's.

06/18/2024 - Isa A.
Very Good !!!

09/16/2018 - Lori Derstine
I was really shocked when I went to pick up my order this evening. I ordered a Lg pizza that was 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 mushroom and 2 dozen buffalo wings and my bill came to $47.64! I couldn't believe how much I was charged! When I got home I looked up my order to see how much it cost on the menu that's online and it looks like either I was overcharged by $10 or Anthony's raised their prices and did not mention anything about it. I'm a regular customer there and my bill usually is around $33 or $34.


It looks like I won't be coming back to Anthony's - I can't afford to be overcharged!

10/31/2013 - Jaimee Wolthers
I have been going to this pizzeria for years. Recently a lot has changed...ALL BAD! New rude management, inconsistent prices listed in their take out menus compared to the prices listed on their website. Then you arrive to pick up your food and end up paying more than any of those listed prices. The quality of food has just gone down hill drastically. I will never return nor would I ever recommend this establishment.

11/25/2012 - Lcal
Great

02/04/2011 - johnny
Phone message says hours are 11-10 yet they would not take orders at 9:45 and i've been drinking all day and jonesing for a chstk.