Reviews for Fish Store

07/15/2025 - Deidra K.
Stopping by to grab a gift card for my father-in-law's birthday led to an unexpectedly warm experience when a kind gentleman offered me a free lunch, insisting that no one should ever go hungry. The fresh, flavorful shrimp and the attentive service reflect the genuine care and dedication found at this old-fashioned fish shop nestled alongside Montauk Highway. From expertly prepared sashimi and sushi by Chef Makoto to comforting seafood dinners and the best homemade rice pudding around, every visit promises fresh, delicious food served with heartfelt hospitality.

06/16/2025 - Freddy
I stumbled across this place and was very pleased with the menu and the tastiness of the food! Staff is mostly comprised of local High School and College kids who are very helpful and pleasant. I have just added this place to my dining list.

While this is mostly a Fish Store the Wings and Burgers are of high quality at a fair price!

04/16/2025 - Ray Rag
Great experience, seafood platter was enjoyable. Love the crab cakes.

06/10/2024 - Marisa A.
LOVE IT!

05/13/2024 - Jonathan H.
I swung by the store to grab a gift card for my father-in-law's birthday and was greeted by a friendly gentleman offering to assist me. As the young lady at the counter handled my purchase, the man surprised me with a complimentary order of shrimp with sauce, ensuring I wouldn't go hungry on my ride home. It's heartwarming to encounter such kindness, and the fresh shrimp was absolutely delightful, making for a fantastic experience at this hidden gem of a fish shop and restaurant.