Reviews for I Love NY Pizza

08/04/2025 - Krista M.
The pizza here totally reminds me of real New York style with the perfect mix of sauce and cheese, always fresh and straight from the oven. The staff is super friendly, and every time I go, I end up grabbing a slice or two along with some garlic knots because it just hits the spot every time.

02/17/2025 - Kristen O.
The pizza here is the best I've found in Georgia, and it brings back memories of New York. Each slice is always hot and fresh, perfectly balanced with sauce and cheese, and the garlic knots are a delicious addition. The friendly staff and inviting atmosphere make it a wonderful experience that keeps me coming back.

05/08/2024 - Von J.
Popping!

12/29/2021 - Josh
Always good and a little different from the normal basic southern pizza

07/20/2020 - Scarlett Bailey
whether i call or go in they automatically know what i want or know who i am. Just love it

05/29/2017 - Greg
Love their Calzanos the best I have had

02/19/2013 - Darin
I Love NY Pizza has great authentic NY-style pizza. I personally love the Original NY Stromboli.