Reviews for All American Pizza

07/19/2024 - Jina H.
On our first Friday in town, we decided to try out "The Pizza Shop" for dinner. Ordering online was convenient, and the drive-thru pickup option was a pleasant surprise. The staff was friendly and the pizza was delicious, with unique offerings like a flatbread-style breadstick and a tasty cookie pizza. We were impressed by the quality of the food and the competitive prices, and we look forward to returning in the future.

06/25/2018 - MenuPix User
Bad

08/08/2015 - Happy Current Customer
Not only is the food better than any big chain, the prices are beyond reasonable. I didn't know what to expect when we went into this tiny, small town pizza place, but I got a pleasant surprise.

07/17/2014 - unhappy former customer
In planning my Monday, I looked up their business hours on their website. It clearly shows they open at 10 AM on Mondays. I ravel led to Tuttle and when I arrived at All American Pizza at about 10:30 AM, they were closed. The hours painted on their glass door indicated 11 AM. I called them and pointed out the discrepancy and inconvenience, and instead of an understanding, accommodating attitude, I received a headstrong, insensitive, "if you don't like it then tough" attitude.