Reviews for Myrtle's Pies
5 stars |
|
37 votes - | 88% | |
4 stars |
|
5 votes - | 12% | |
3 stars |
|
0 votes - | 0% | |
2 stars |
|
0 votes - | 0% | |
1 star |
|
0 votes - | 0% |
Latest MenuPix Reviews
05/04/2024 - Inga L.
100% on point
09/21/2023 - Kris
A good friend of mine is from IL and when she comes to visit me in another state, she uses a large cooler and brings along 2 pies--coconut cream and french silk. OH MY GOODNESS! I haven't tasted the coconut cream but others who eat it say it's fabulous. But the french silk--everything is perfect. The creaminess and texture of the chocolate, the chocolate lining the crust, etc. I can't recommend it enough. I don't eat many sweets and only splurge when it's worth it--that french silk is worth it! Enjoy!
09/05/2023 - Barb Berrios
My daughter was in princeton with her Boyfriend over labor day weekend and I brought back pies. I absolutely love the coconut cream pie and the pumpkin pie both were delicious. I wish we lived closer, we live in Aurora Illinois. They packed up the pies in a big cooler with ice.
03/06/2022 - MenuPix User
There are so many delicious options in a welcoming friendly shop.
01/27/2022 - Jay Jacobson
Handmade crust, premium ingredients and made to perfection. I could have spent a lot more time in this cafe’. My only suggestion is that if you come, come with four or five of your closest friends ( ones that will let you try their pie). So many flavors to choose from. You’ll enjoy your selection but you may regret the one that got away.
12/01/2021 - MenuPix User
Great staff and excellent pies every time!
08/25/2021 - MenuPix User
Best pie 🥧 ever 😋
07/15/2021 - MenuPix User
Coconut cream pie is OMGGG DELISH!!!!
02/14/2021 - MenuPix User
I had a slice of apple pie The best I ever had
06/12/2020 - De kimble
Staff and David always greet with a smile. And the pies are the best. love banana cream and rubarb are my favorite.
05/10/2020 - Barb McKinney
The pies are just like my gramas. Love the flaky crust.
04/11/2020 - Karen from Rochelle
Love the pies! Looking forward to being able to get out and about in order to enjoy your pie. Rob, too. The Staff at The Roadhouse in Oregon, IL also like your pies that we share with them.
04/30/2017 - Marcia Dukes
Beth Hall brought my friend and me each a pie. I have never had a peach pie so delicious. The lemon meringue was to die for.
05/31/2014 - B.D.
The food was amazing. I had the quiche with potato planks and a piece of the lemon/raspberry pie. The atmosphere is friendly and clean. Can't wait to get back.