Reviews for Gary's Oyster Shack

04/16/2025 - Sara T.
The oyster basket I enjoyed was fantastic, while my wife savored the scallops. The service was polite and attentive, making our dining experience even better. This charming spot offers delicious seafood, and I can't wait to return to try their Prime Rib special on Thursdays!

04/21/2024 - Dottie A.
Buzzing

08/12/2023 - Butlerrs
Amazing food, comfortable pleasing atmosphere, outstanding service. Good value.

08/18/2022 - Michelle
Best blackened grouper anywhere! Fresh and huge portions! Also great pies! Love their house dressing. Very reasonable price too!

08/26/2021 - Jack
Very enjoyable experience. Absolutely delicious meal,(wife had the lunch stack and myself shrimp/grouper basket). Pleasant music, very nice waitress, and met Gary. Awesome guy, we will absolutely put this little gem in our rotation!!!

10/29/2015 - Sheila
Amazing food at a great price with honest people! I love eating here!

07/16/2015 - Ciara Brady
Best restaurant In town!!! Food is the best ever!! And service the best ever!! I am so addicted to their food. I highly recommend this place. Please go eat there, I promise you will not ever be disappointed. Fresh seafood always! !!

02/16/2014 - Cathy
Husband and I took a weekend trip & just drove by and decided to stop OMG am I glad we did. Small place,but husband,wife and son made us feel welcomed and they served us the BEST seafood that we had the whole time we were there. My only regret is that we didn't go back before we left. A big must go back!