Reviews for Massey's Pizza

07/21/2025 - Nicole R.
The pizza here bursts with generous toppings and a flavorful crust that immediately takes me back to the classic pies I grew up enjoying in Reynoldsburg. Whether grabbing a deep dish like the Godfather or indulging in the buffet, each bite delivers that perfect balance of savory sauce, melty cheese, and hearty meat, making every visit a satisfying experience.

07/17/2024 - Silvia G.
always good

04/19/2024 - Danielle M.
I recently tried Massey's Pizza in Lancaster and was thoroughly impressed. The quality of their toppings, the flavorful crust, and the overall value make it a standout choice for pizza lovers. I highly recommend giving Massey's a try if you're in the area - you won't be disappointed!

02/07/2021 - MenuPix User
Best Pizza in town !!.Any time family comes from out of town, always wants to go to Massey's. Bob makes the best pizza.You definitely get your moneys worth.

05/07/2020 - MenuPix User
This was our 2nd time getting pizza at this store. Was burnt . Should of never let a pizza go out looking like this. We should of looked at it before we left. Masseys in Whitehall is great. Always great... I'm sure this is something that can be fixed.