Reviews for Brooklyn Pizzeria

07/18/2023 - Evelyn cram
Came to Bay St. Louis in 2021, 2022, coming back in July 2023. My son lives there,he introduced us to your pizza. Your pizza was very, very, good.

04/28/2023 - Jerry
Pizza is on point and the Italian roll is probably the best non pizza dish that I’ve ever eaten in ANY Italian /pizza ship. It’s genuinely that freaking good. However , and this is why the 3 stars, the service or lack there of should I say is an issue. Listen I run a dealership so I know how important it is to try to close on time but this place is on another level, I’ve been in twice and both times I witnessed a different type of issues customers had that were due to “closing time”. The first one was my own personal family , after standing outside BLIND TIGER fir 45 mins waiting for a table I finally told my wife to call Brooklyn and make sure that they were still seating a table of 5 adults 4 kids an hour before closing to be safe. She was told no problem, so we hop on the golf cart in the rain and shoot over. Walk in and it smelled great the family sits and my wife I walk to register only to be told “so we’re out of a few things, mmmmmmmm wellllllllll pretty much I guess the only thing we’re still doing is pizza. So much for the sandwich I wanted but whatever pizza was good. Tonight I call in an order and driver over to pick it up. I walk in at 7:19 and kind u all the chairs we turned over and since it didn’t involve me I kept quiet but then a really nice older 2 gentleman in front of me so nicely and with the thickest country accent “says ma’am we’ll clean up after ourselves if you’ll let us sit at one of these tables , I promise it’ll be spotless. So the youglady calls over the owner and he repeats him self this time adding if we could eat here due to my house being burnt down we no longer have a table , punched me in the gut. Her only response was noooooo sorry these kids that work here gotta get home for school tomorrow. 🤦‍♂️, listen I hate writing a review like this cuz people only post when it’s bad and I know that so I need reiterate there food is amazing and on point , I just think maybe someone else who doesn’t mind working the longer hours can take over and it would be a first class dining experience. The current owners are probably worn out after all these years and tired of the grind. Long story short I loved the food bust just am aware of circumstances out of the ordinary cause the efficiency and the experience to be way less than the 5 stars it deserved

07/30/2022 - Karen
Great Italians salad

09/07/2020 - Jamie Temple
the most authentic New York Pizza i have found in the south!

06/27/2019 - David Blackmon
Best hand tossed pie around! Don't miss it!