Reviews for Brooklyn Water Bagels

08/01/2025 - Carlo Q.
Brooklyn Water Bagel serves up bagels that are crunchy on the outside and perfectly doughy inside, making it my go-to for Sunday morning breakfasts. The whitefish salad and cream cheese combos hit the spot, and the coffee is solid, even if their iced tea took a nosedive after switching suppliers-murky drinks are a definite bummer. The staff here has seriously stepped up their game with friendly, understanding service, always ready to fix any mix-ups, which keeps me coming back despite some minor hiccups.

06/12/2024 - Melissa L.
Recently had breakfast at Brooklyn Water Bagel. Enjoyed an everything bagel with whitefish salad, while my wife had a cinnamon bagel with cream cheese. The coffee was good, but the coffee bar could use some maintenance. Despite that, the service was pleasant and the overall experience was enjoyable.