Reviews for The Manhattan Firehouse

02/22/2021 - J.D.
Corned Beef Sandwich was soggy. Italian Beef has a strange flavored spice. French fries were cold and cut too small. Mushrooms is beer batter not so good. I also avoided ordering hot dogs as they are not all beef.
I was so hoping for a better replacement at this location after Nicky's moved out.

05/25/2019 - MenuPix User
Ordered 2 hamburgers and Italian beef it took an extremely long time. Ended up taking home the hamburgers were over cooked and the fries were overdone yet soggy like they were cooked in oil hours before. There were no hot lamps. There were three men behind the counter and when I approached the counter one gentlemen was standing at the prep station and he must have taken 5 minutes to figure out how to wrap the hamburgers in foil. Then read each bag, yes they actually bagged each item in their own bag. The young man looked at each bag and instead of taking the item that was written on each bag. He read one then placed it on the counter, picked each of the other two bags, like he was expected to place a particular item in first. This was painstaking ! Poor service plus bad food equals thirty dollars! Does not compute, never again!