Reviews for Joey's New York Pizza & Italian Restaurant

07/06/2025 - Samantha Z.
Joey's New York Restaurant delivers authentic New York-style pizza, pasta, soups, and salads with generous portions and fresh ingredients that consistently satisfy. The staff is friendly and attentive, creating a welcoming atmosphere, whether dining in or ordering takeout and delivery. With a wide variety of delicious dishes and weekday specials, it's become my go-to for hearty Italian meals that remind me of classic New York flavors.

07/07/2024 - August E.
Always good.

02/15/2023 - Nikki
Chicken Francese was loaded with black pepper. Total overkill, not enough lemon. Greasy garlic knots that leaked through the bag. It was so freaking wet with oil, that's all you taste. The salad wasn't the freshest. $20 + and not worth it.

01/20/2023 - Former regular
I have always been a big Joey's fan since it opened. Not sure what has happened in the past year. Service is slow and constant staff turn overs. My chicken sorentino had very little sauce, and wasn't the same quality. Just sad :(

01/15/2023 - Debbie
The past few times have been terrible food cold - pasta seems old and reheated same with vegetables. Delivery time is long. Very disappointing as they use to be so good!!

06/11/2022 - MenuPix User
The Joeys here doesn't live up to the traditional quality name that this company has built. Everything was under cooked and extremely bland. Please hire a new cook as I could've bought something considerably better from the frozen food section of Publix.

09/28/2020 - Joe Waked
Gabriel the waiter and the hostess gave us excellent service..they were very kind as well!!! I enjoyed the atmosphere! I would recommend this for a great place to eat!!! Food was xcellent!

08/29/2020 - Old Painter
Always great pizza, antipasto salad. And when we go in for a dinner ...great service with great tasting Italian food!! We are so glad they are nearby.

04/13/2020 - Michele
Great food!!! The best Italian food we ever had. Excellent service. Great employees. Luv the atmosphere we highly recommend this to all of our friends. We rate this place 10 stars.