Reviews for One Eyed Jack's

07/11/2025 - T Y.
Driving through Winamac, I discovered a diner with an unassuming exterior but a welcoming old-west parlor interior and an atmosphere filled with friendly service. The pork tenderloin sandwich here was colossal, with perfectly crisp, in-house battered pork that was so tender it almost tasted like chicken, complemented beautifully by fresh toppings and a side of expertly brewed sweet tea. From the generous portions of smelts and whitefish to the extensive craft beer list and tempting desserts, every bite and sip made the wait and the 45-minute drive completely worthwhile.

11/13/2023 - Dawn
Prepare to bring home a box of Great food for next meal.

07/18/2023 - MenuPix User
If you're looking for a awesome tenderloin you need to travel to one eye Jack's , this just went to the top of my tenderloin trails list!!!!

06/27/2022 - MenuPix User
Best tenderloin ever and the portobello mushrooms deep fried to perfection. Menu offers lots of choices.