Reviews for John Sullivan's Bar and Grill

05/25/2025 - Ely S.
The service here was fantastic, with Michele and Xavier making sure we felt right at home while we enjoyed some seriously flavorful dishes like the homemade breaded tenders and shepherd's pie. The drinks were cold and tasty-I loved my fig cosmo and the bartender was super friendly and welcoming, adding to the chill atmosphere perfect for a Sunday night or a pre-MSG show stop. It's usually packed after work, but the vibe is never too rowdy, so whether you're grabbing a quick drink or sitting down for a meal, it's a solid spot to unwind and enjoy great food and company.

09/30/2024 - Michael M.
The service was efficient and the beverages were refreshing. I savored the homemade breaded tenders, bursting with flavor. It's a popular spot, especially during the evenings, but we found a cozy corner for lunch. Our server, Michele, was attentive and accommodating, helping us make our choices effortlessly.

04/24/2024 - Mitchel A.
Excellent

09/06/2017 - John Gallagher
Started working on 35th and, coming from Ireland, was delighted to see this place virtually across the road. It was my birthday and decided to treat myself to an Irish breakfast so I visited this establishment. The first clue should have been when it took the hostess a good two minutes to acknowledge me, after she was finished with her texting!! I was served by a nice native Irish girl who was very engaging and helpful. That was as good as it got. I ordered the Irish breakfast, what a disappointment. The chef managed to slice the pudding into the thinnest slices I have ever seen, a skill on it's own!! I did enjoy the beans, all 28 of them, yes I counted. The overeasy eggs looked good on the plate but, were completely burnt underneath. The white bread toast and the tea they managed to get right!! Not cheap and even if it was it would still not have been worth the money. I guess I will be traveling further for my next Irish breakfast.