Reviews for NY Pie

07/28/2025 - Jessica B.
The hand-tossed pizzas here feature fresh sauces and cheeses with a thin, crispy crust that holds a generous amount of toppings, making the 18-inch pie perfect for sharing with family. The service is friendly and efficient, the environment clean and welcoming, and the menu offers a variety of options including calzones and garlic knots, all consistently delivering a delicious and authentic New York-style pizza experience.

10/05/2024 - Antonella S.
The pizzeria in Hendersonville offers the tastiest hand-tossed pies with simple, fresh sauces and cheeses. Their very large 18-inch pizza easily feeds a family of four, making it a child-friendly spot where kids can even play with some dough while waiting. The classic NY-style pizza is similar to what you'd find up north, with quick service, good flavor in the sauce, fresh toppings, and a generous portion size that will have you coming back for more.

07/02/2024 - Scarlet J.
Mood forever