Reviews for Supreme Pizza

07/19/2025 - Mae K.
I brought my family here for lunch and we all enjoyed the chicken finger dinner, cheese pizza, chicken cutlet sub, and baked ziti, which arrived hot, fresh, and delicious with generous portions at good prices. The cozy and clean atmosphere combined with friendly, professional staff made the experience even better, and the supreme pizza with its crispy crust and flavorful sauce quickly became a favorite. On another occasion, I appreciated their quick, accurate delivery service directly to our team bus, and the thoughtful touches like supporting school funds through tipping made me feel truly valued as a customer.

07/18/2024 - Charles Y.
Thank you for the 5-star review! I'm glad to hear that you and your family enjoyed your meal at Supreme Pizza. The generous portions, cozy environment, and friendly staff are what set us apart. We appreciate your feedback and look forward to serving you again soon.

05/30/2024 - Juli P.
They did THAT

06/25/2023 - Cynthia Rose
Local, fresh and family run.

01/09/2022 - Ralph
Best meat lovers in town without a doubt!!!

12/02/2021 - Rachel
Best pizza! MUCH better quality than the fancy pizza places in town! Thin crust goes almost out to the edge, someone has talent - and the toppings are actually fresh! I'm always disappointed if I order spinach topping, but with these folks it's near-crispy. Also, their Greek salad dressing is the real thing - I'm always afraid they will run out of it and substitute Wishbone, but they never do.
Things have not been great for my family during this covid-time we are all going through, and honestly, when I just need to cheer up a bit, I order their pizza, delivered. It works. Thanks, Supreme.

05/05/2021 - Jaki
The best in town for consistency, good always.

07/06/2019 - MenuPix User
Awsome food. great pizza. best greek salad. everyone says best hot dog in town

07/31/2018 - Shelby H.
Spend the week in Falmouth last week. We ordered from Supreme Pizza twice. Both times, the pizza was excellent. My wife ordered the greek salad both times and loved it.

11/03/2017 - Wendy
Used to be good on delivery but not any more. Prime time much better