Reviews for Setauket Seafood

08/01/2025 - Kristen H.
The seafood here is always fresh with a wide variety to choose from, and the owners are very knowledgeable and honest about the quality of their products. They offer excellent customer service, including helpful advice on ingredients and the option to have lobsters cooked, making it a reliable source for premium seafood that my family truly enjoys.

06/17/2025 - MenuPix User
Setauket Seafood is not SeaPort Deli

07/30/2024 - Bettie C.
Setauket Seafood offers an incredible variety of fresh, high-quality seafood. The friendly family who runs the store will guide you through your choices and ensure you leave with the best products for your needs.

05/24/2024 - Xiomara S.
Always a good meal

12/07/2021 - Ann
The best fresh fish and fair prices and super good

11/08/2020 - MenuPix User
best seafood in this area! excellent curbside pick up! Nice folks, (especially Eddie) are very helpful!

08/23/2020 - Marge McDonagh
The best--six stars for their shrimp cocktail and fresh fish. Matt & Eddie are very pleasant And miss him in St. James. Lots of St James people travel to Setauket to buy their fish.