Reviews for Cafe Rinaldi

08/22/2025 - Jeanne J.
The consistently delicious food here, from the fabulous layered pizza to the fresh homemade pasta and generous risotto portions, never fails to impress me with its quality and flavor. The friendly, attentive staff make every visit enjoyable, and the reasonable prices combined with the cozy, unpretentious atmosphere keep me coming back time and again.

02/08/2025 - Sammie H.
Twice a year, I find myself drawn to this culinary haven, where the consistency of deliciousness never wavers. The atmosphere feels welcoming, and the care put into every dish-especially the homemade pasta and layered pizza-ensures each visit is a comforting experience that lingers long after the last bite.

06/16/2024 - Megan M.
Good place

11/21/2022 - Morgan
Ordered take out chicken parmesean over zita's with meatballs. The sauce was absolutely fantastic & the meal was to die for. They give you a very large portion size & it even tasted very scrumptious the next day. 5 Star Rating.

11/24/2021 - Janet G
I never was disappointed with meals n drinks every time we came here! The food is scrumptious and staff friendly!! Owner is great also! Can't to our table n made us feel comfy! This is our " to go" place in Old Forge!! 👍

08/01/2020 - Jacki marie
Best Risotto ! Also love the Sole franchise and sauteed spinach. Always a good meal there

05/13/2020 - MenuPix User
Mother's Day meals were not good standing for a long time in bag.....

08/24/2019 - MenuPix User
Our favorite Italian restaurant in Old Forge! Always good and friendly service . And the food is always delicious.

04/29/2015 - Tina
Everytime I come here the atmosphere is unfriendly and nobody smiles. Each time I come I feel like I am a bother. Definitely not a warm place. Food ok. I have had much better. Atmosphere too dark. Sad!