Reviews for Peppino's Tomato Pies

05/03/2025 - Tyler S.
The Barstool rating of 7.8 doesn't do this place justice; I'd give it an 8.5 for the old fashioned tomato pie alone. The crispy thin crust, fresh ingredients, and friendly service from Chef Andy make it a must-visit, and I can't wait to try more of the menu!

06/02/2020 - Gwen
I haven't tasted a hoagie like this since I was a kid!
I tell everybody how great this place is !!!

05/16/2020 - Barry B
Exceptional food.The Old fashion tomato pie with the cheese on the bottom is the best I've ever had.

04/16/2020 - Linda T.
My husband raves about the antipasto. A real South Philly flavor offered with every dish. The pies are made to perfection. We highly recommend Peppino's if you' in the mood for true Italian flavor.

09/06/2019 - Flo
Food is amazing, great pies and sandwiches, the owners are very friendly

06/26/2019 - MenuPix User
Excellent tomato pie and the cutlets taste just like my grandmoms