Reviews for Coy's Store & Pizza Shop

06/19/2024 - Sergio R.
My last meal in Pennsylvania before my move was at Coy's, where I enjoyed their famous pizza without much convincing needed. Watching the constant stream of people picking up orders, I opted to eat in and savor the delicious pizza fresh at the table with customizable toppings.

05/18/2024 - Jose L.
Always delicious!

08/26/2023 - MenuPix User
Best pizza I ever had. Clean establishment great customer service.

05/18/2016 - Donna
I was a bit surprised that a small pizza and a large were 30 dollars But their pizza is good

05/19/2015 - Unhappy customer
Food was not good, dirty establishment, and Shawna was rude.
Will never recommend.

03/26/2015 - Donna
Food is always amazing, best pizza around! Wish they would give out an occasional coupon to faithful customers....I highly doubt they ever told anyone to "deal with it" if they called with a complaint about the food being "burnt". I had gotten a salad once and the chicken was a little over cooked, I called and they were extremely apologetic! Even offered to make it right. You won't be disappointed!

07/24/2014 - B StClair
Never disappointed, soup was delicious, interested in gluten free pizza

05/24/2014 - molly young
Best buffalo chicken pizza around! It is a bit sloppy but it is SO GOOD!

06/02/2013 - michael bignar
food was burnt called and told them it was burnt and they told me to deal with it