Reviews for Timmys New Milford Cafe

02/10/2025 - Veronica F.
I discovered this cafe last summer and have returned many times since. The wings are the best I've ever had, especially on Tuesday wing nights, and I love the daily specials like $1.00 beers on Wednesdays. The atmosphere is fun, and the friendly staff always makes for a great dining experience.

12/22/2024 - Beth
Food is great but this online menu has the WRONG prices in it. As of 12/24 a dozen wings are $15.99 not $10.49.

04/27/2024 - Mohamad J.
Dope!

06/07/2023 - John
A definite step when in ohio

11/05/2022 - Debbi
Great service even tho we were the only ones on the patio (and unusual awesome day for it) Food was delicious and definitely will be back to try other menu items! Made me feel like I was back home in NY, good music, service & food!

09/19/2021 - Ginny
new milfird cafe no longer exists. If you want information on this place please look up Timmy's New Milford cafe. We are on fb. We Have awesome food specials and a great staff.
4927 Greenwood in Rootstown since 1941.

03/02/2020 - Hope Brown
Good times great food.people a always awesome.