Reviews for Garden Of Eating Pizzeria

08/08/2025 - Tye B.
The aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air as I pick up my order, the crust perfectly crisp and the cheese rich and flavorful. The friendly staff always greets me with a smile, making the quick carryout experience feel warm and welcoming every time. Whether it's the hearty antipasto salad, a toasted sub, or their generous calzones, each bite reminds me why this neighborhood favorite has been cherished for decades.

11/18/2024 - Nicole Z.
I always have a great experience at Garden of Eating. The pizza is delicious, the staff is friendly, and the convenience of carryout makes it a go-to choice for me in the neighborhood.

04/25/2021 - Anjelica
The food, when it's correct, is excellent! Problem is the shop cannot seem get an order right consistently. I order the same thing every time, specific toppings on a pizza. It's been right 1 time in the last 5 orders. Maybe I'm an idiot to keep trying... but the food is genuinely good. It's slow, (generally an hour+) which would be worth it if it was correct. I'm done trying. Moving on to decent pizza that's consistently correct & great delivery time, instead of the crap shoot it is to order from here.

12/28/2012 - James C
I love the place. I am 49 yrs old and it is right there with the best for economy and good food. I have traveled all over this country in my years for a perspective. Well I admit their food isn't dripping with grease like a lot of people want. Try the "Make your own calzone" with any toppings and ricotta, feta, and provalone. Put anything or everything on it. You can feed three for under $4.00 a piece with their huge large. I just love the place and they are always fast for me.

02/09/2012 - JP
called to place an order the lady that answered the phone just answered with a hello when I asked if this was the right place she had a bad attitude as I continued to place my order she acted like she hated life and just wanted to get off the phone at the end i asked to pay with a card and she very rudely told me it would be over an hour wait for my order I then decided i did not want to do business with people like that.