Reviews for Jay's Pizza

09/07/2024 - Natalia K.
The pizza is outstanding, one of the top spots in Pittsburgh. The white pizza is a must-try, always fresh and delicious.

06/07/2024 - Shelly R.
very good

04/22/2022 - Jim Cairns
Been eating this pizza for 30 yrs, it's always been great!!

09/21/2021 - MenuPix User
The food is wonderful and reasonably priced.

03/13/2021 - jg
was there on friday for fish. it was a little hectic in there as it was very busy but the fish sandwich was worth it. one of if not the best fish sandwiches i've had.

01/22/2021 - Dodie
Just had a great fish sandwich. I would highly recommend it to anyone. So far have had only great food from day one of the reopening.

01/19/2021 - MenuPix User
Had pizza from jays today it was a little doughy had to much cheese and not enough sauce. Last time we had it it was pretty good. Doesn't seem to be any consistency.

10/14/2017 - Bev Lyle
Grew up on Jay's Pizza BEST Ever !! MISS YA JAY AN FAMILY !!

01/15/2017 - Jack
I left McDonald back in the 1970's. I now live in Texas and as often as I can I fly to Pittsburgh so I can eat Jay's Pizza it is so good. . Back in the day the pizza shop was located next to Mathias Bakery before it moved to its current location. Old Mrs. Boneysteele cooked many hamburgers for this kid. I will be flying to Pittsburgh in May of 2017 from Texas just to eat some pizza and then I will fly back to Texas.

08/09/2013 - Don
Great pizza! Needs to get menu online.