Reviews for Joey's Pizza

10/14/2023 - James
Stay far, far away !!!one of the worse interactions I ever had with an owner of any business.

I called up to order a bruschetta deep dish pie. I asked the girl on the phone how thick it is and she told me basically in-between a scicilian and regular pie. So I ordered it.

I picked up the pie and when I got home it turned out to be a thin crust scicillian with barely any cheese on it. See pictures

So I called back and spoke to the owner. He basically told me to go F myself. This is the way he makes it and he has been making it this way for 30 years. I tried to explain to him what the girl told me on the phone but he didn't want to hear it and called me a liar.

I can forgive the pizza but not an owner who talks to his customers that way.

$26 for aa pizza that is about as thick as cardboard, has very little cheese and was very bland. Save your money and go to John's of Arthur Ave in Milford instead.

01/06/2020 - Diane S.
Thank you, Joey’s Pizza for serving this Milford Borough Community, with pride, for over 20 years. Your food is consistently good, fresh, tasty, affordable in a family-friendly atmosphere. Your staff is friendly and courteous.
Joey’s Pizza knows the ‘real’ Milford..
Milford knows the ‘real’ Joey’s Pizza where respect and appreciation complement the menu. Diane S.