Reviews for Lizzy's Ice Cream & Sandwich

03/22/2024 - MenuPix User

03/15/2024 - MenuPix User

11/09/2023 - MenuPix User

11/01/2023 - MenuPix User

08/30/2023 - MenuPix User
I buy from them alot they have my name and have delivered 100 times so tonight the wife and kids wanted ice-cream I called ordered it just to be told no we don't take cash!!! So no order and I won't buy from there again.... my business is gone!!!

05/08/2020 - Liz Weber
The new owner has done an AMAZING job with the menu: fresh, fresh, fresh and very good!

06/26/2019 - Tony Fletcher
This is one of the best little ice cream & sandwhich shops Greencastle, I've been coming there for years under the old management and the new management hasn't lost the quality, if anything they are improving the menu, Keep up the good work guy's and I'll see you soon.😀😀😉👌

05/30/2016 - Lori
The icecream is good - I'll give 1 star for that - however the food is terrible!! Chicken sandwiches are just cooked with no flavoring - white I color like they were boiled - rolls dry - pizza burger just strange tasting meat with some spaghetti sauce (cold) on top - never again for hot "food"

01/21/2016 - Brian
My fiancé and myself love going to this place! they have very good food and a friendly atmosphere that we enjoy. The signature burger is delicious. There are many flavors of ice cream too, stop by and enjoy!