Reviews for Mi Scuzi Restaurant

03/31/2025 - Joni S.
This cozy and inviting restaurant offers a calming atmosphere, perfect for a romantic dinner. The food is truly exceptional, from the fresh seafood to the divine desserts, and the service is friendly and attentive. With a charming ambiance and a great wine selection, this is definitely a dining experience worth repeating.

11/16/2024 - Jan H.
The atmosphere was welcoming and peaceful, making it an ideal choice for a low-key evening out. The cuisine was flavorful and the service was attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. I look forward to returning in the future to enjoy more of the delicious offerings.

05/29/2024 - Dustin W.
Quaint

07/13/2014 - Mike melter
First off NO parking and you have to pay for valet? HA!
The food is Overpriced and Far from "authentic" canned mushrooms. Canned gravy. One of us got spaghetti for $20 and had to spend an extra $5 for a salad, it's all seperate
It is cramped in the dining area and smells musty. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone. Ramen noodles is closer to authentic
The owner mike came around I expressed my feeling on the prices, no parking, and hostess with a bad attitude. He made excuses and was rude.
HORRIBLE!!
I asked why bud light isn't carried, he said they don't carry it because he doesn't want the "rifraf" in there... Well I like BL, so I'm "riffraff"
I'll never be back an will let everyone know about mike and his attitude.

01/12/2014 - Anne Mathewson
Absolutely amazing - every mouth watering bite!

03/30/2011 - Chuck Cerniglia
Having owned an Italian Restaurant for many years I feel very qualified to evaluate a restaurant especially an Italian restaurant. the first thing that impressed me about the food was its' freshness. all made from scratch. Each Entrée was very flavorful and like I said "FRESH" the service was excellent and prices were reasonable. an excellent value and pleasureful dining experience. We enjoyed our meal and all future trips east will go through Erie.

01/12/2011 - Jim Collins
My wife and I quickly made this our favorite restaurant after hearing about it from a friend. We live 40 miles away, but it is worth the drive. Sorry I'm not familiar with Italian names, but the house salad, filet mignon, and breaded chicken in a kind of red sauce are all GREAT! I highly recommend this fine Italian restaurant!!

08/09/2010 - Dave P
i have to say, this is one of the best Italian restaurants i have been to. I am of Italian heritage, and i was not disappointed. We were in Erie visiting out daughter, found this through a friend, and i wanted to go back every night we were in town, and should have.....

try the fresh tomato salad, to the eggplant par, to the penne with vodka sauce.....